The 48-year-old singer has revealed that Jason - who quit the group in 2014 - had decided he simply ''didn't want to do it anymore'' and despite Gary spending ''about a year'' trying to convince Jason to change his mind, he wasn't tempted to return.
Gary said to the Metro newspaper: ''He just didn't want to do it anymore. I don't think he'll come back.
''It's one thing when you're teenagers talking someone into something but he's a man now.
''We tried to talk him into it for about a year. We tried everything. Guilt. He just didn't want to do it.''
But following the departures of Jason and Robbie, Gary admitted that if another member were to leave the group, the remaining duo would have to rebrand.
He said: ''It can't go to two. We've made an agreement that it can't go to two and if it does, we've got to find a new name.''
As for Gary's highlights with the band, he claims there have been ''thousands'', admitting it's an ''amazing feeling'' to perform alongside his good pals.
He said: ''There have been thousands [of highlights].
''I remember the night we did the Olympics [in 2012] where we all turned to face each other and it's an amazing thing looking at your mates with millions of people around the world watching you. You think 'How have we got here?' You feel like a fraud every day.''
'Devour You' is a fantastic follow up to Starcrawler's debut album and represents a move on in terms of sound and, in part, direction.
Salvation Jayne's third birthday bash was a riot of colour and a celebration of a band very much enjoying what they do.
We're feeling the nostalgia this month.
American Thighs was released on this day in 1994.
Gloo is a new supergroup consisting of UK mystic-beat producers Iglooghost and Kai Whiston as well as nu-pop singer/producer BABii.
Listen to her new single Forgive Me now.
His new album Underneath It All is out now.