David Kirschner

David Kirschner

David Kirschner Quick Links

Film RSS

Miss Potter Review


Weak

Chris Noonan's Miss Potter continues a rather long line of films that attempt to diagnose the creative process of a writer and the critical world that surrounds the writer's inherent social (emotional) ineptitude. There are moments where Miss Potter seems to be on the right track in feeling out the emotional trajectory of its main character, but it often chooses the route of greater cuteness over the challenges of trying to study the life of a writer.

Beatrix Potter (Renée Zellweger) came from a well-off family and was well past her marriage date when three brothers agreed to publish her book, expecting nothing more than a minor profit. In case the name doesn't ring a bell, Miss Potter was the brains behind the beloved Peter Rabbit and several other indelible creatures of delightful fantasy. When the elder statesmen of the publishing firm deem the project unworthy of their time, they send their young brother (Ewan McGregor), to handle the book and its flighty author. As you may guess, the two fall head-over-heels, much to the chagrin of Beatrix's parents (Bill Patterson and Barbara Flynn) and to the glee of his sister (Emily Watson, the film's most evident charm factory).

Noonan, best known for the now classic Babe, treats his subject with the same well-dressed adorability that Potter gave her creatures, most notably Peter. A more easygoing version of Marc Forster's Finding Neverland, Miss Potter spends more time striving to deal with the relationship status of its heroine than delving into the quixotic charm of her writing process. The better parts of the film are the flourishes of animated hallucinogenics that Noonan puts in as a reminder of where these creations came from: Beatrix's parlor of emotional eccentricities.

The problem is that, when push comes to shove, we've seen Potter's story before, and Miss Potter is severely lacking in trying to differentiate its source material from any other classically-tinted story of love and writing. Acting-wise, there couldn't be a sweeter bunch of actors to add to the candy-coated shell the film inhabits. But the film invariably goes for impenetrable cuteness, even when a rather obvious tragedy occurs. In fact, all the drama that arises seems to be treated with fumbling, patronizing dullness to give more ample weight to what is a rather wanting character study.

Rereading the Peter Rabbit books, you have to marvel at the simplicity and class that the books had in telling a story with a solid moral. What Miss Potter doesn't have is the creative veil that Potter herself gave these wonderful stories. The film could have been so detailed and surreal, yet it relies on whimsy like the animated whirl of Beatrix's parents stepping into a cartoon pumpkin led by four monstrous rabbits. It is missing that childlike love for nature and animals that Beatrix must have had, and in turn, forgets what it's like to have an imagination.

Not Harry's mom.

David Kirschner

David Kirschner Quick Links

Film RSS
Advertisement

Occupation

Filmmaker


Suggested

Be Kind: Songs to inspire compassion in a world of conflict [Playlist]

Be Kind: Songs to inspire compassion in a world of conflict [Playlist]

Looks like we need to learn basic humanity again.

Album of the Week: We're joining Deee-Lite's World Clique

Album of the Week: We're joining Deee-Lite's World Clique

'World Clique' was released on this day (August 7th) in 1990.

Meme of the Week: The best

Meme of the Week: The best "I'm secretly listening to" posts on Twitter

We have never been called out so hard by a meme in our lives.

Billie Eilish - My Future Video

Billie Eilish - My Future Video

Billie Eilish is back with possibly her most chilled out song yet. 'My Future' comes alongside a melancholy animated video starring Billie herself.

Advertisement
Seven greatest movie soundtracks of the 90s

Seven greatest movie soundtracks of the 90s

The 90s was the greatest decade for movie soundtracks. Change our minds.

Taylor Swift - Cardigan Video

Taylor Swift - Cardigan Video

Taylor Swift goes from lively pop to a more dreamy vibe with her newly released album 'Folklore', and she has unveiled an appropriate video for her...

Does One Direction still have a place in a DIY decade of music? [Opinion]

Does One Direction still have a place in a DIY decade of music? [Opinion]

Would a permanent hiatus be the best choice for the much-loved boyband?

Album of the Week: Paolo Nutini takes us back to 'These Streets'

Album of the Week: Paolo Nutini takes us back to 'These Streets'

'These Streets' was released on this day (July 17th) in 2006.

Advertisement

David Kirschner Movies

Miss Potter Movie Review

Miss Potter Movie Review

Chris Noonan's Miss Potter continues a rather long line of films that attempt to diagnose...

Artists
Actors
    Filmmakers
      Artists
      Bands
        Musicians
          Artists
          Celebrities
             
              Artists
              Interviews