Quote: "We turned right back into our 16-year-old selves and acted like idiots. It's fun to see the cast married and as parents. I shot American Pie during my senior year of high school, and it was all about girls. Now it's about couples and babies!" American Pie actor Eddie Kaye Thomas, who plays Paul Finch in the hit franchise, enjoyed reconnecting with his old pals for the upcoming sequel, American Reunion.